| Noah | Forrey | Beloit College | D3 | | Petaluma HS | 2013 |
| Ilon | Zur | UC Santa Cruz | D3 | | Summerfield Waldorf HS | 2013 |
| Noah | Everly | Sonoma State | D2 | | San Marin HS | 2014 |
| Aren | Ulmer | University of West Georgia | D2 | | St. Mary's College HS | 2015 |
| Jasper | Verduin | Chapman University | D3 | | Archie Williams HS | 2015 |
| Colton | Wirth | Menlo College | NAIA | | San Marin HS | 2015 |
| Joe | Hoeup | Cambodia National Team | NATIONAL | | Elsie Allen HS / Hardin-Simmons University | 2015 |
| Keith | Smith | GBA Lions (Czech Republic) | PRO | | San Ramon Valley HS / VMI / Cal Poly SLO | 2015 |
| Jordan | Ratinho | University of San Francisco | D1 | | De La Salle HS | 2016 |
| Ryan | Perez | Montana St. University Billings | D2 | | Petaluma HS | 2016 |
| Sepehr | Agnese | Kenyon College | D3 | | Marin Catholic HS | 2016 |
| James | Finn | Middlebury College | D3 | | Tamalpais HS | 2016 |
| Dempsey | Roggenbuck | Linfield College | D3 | | Marin Catholic / Prolific Prep | 2016 |
| Gabe | Knight | University of Saint Katherine | NAIA | | Windsor / Santa Rosa JC | 2016 |
| Landon | Courtman | Cal State Maritime | NAIA | | Healdsburg HS / Westmont / Santa Rosa JC | 2017 |
| Jordan | Jackson | Warner Pacific University | NAIA | Junior | Tamalpais HS / College of Marin / College of Alameda | 2017 |
| Joey | Potts | CSA Steaua (Romania) | PRO | | Petaluma HS / College of Marin / Oregon State / Oregon Tech | 2017 |
| Ethan | Menzies | Colorado Mesa | D2 | RS Junior | Half Moon Bay / Cushing Academy | 2018 |
| Aaron | Porcil | Converse University | D2 | | Vanden HS / Sonoma State / Santa Rosa JC | 2018 |
| Brandon | Beckman | University of Chicago | D3 | | St. Ignatius College Preparatory | 2018 |
| Noah | Bice | Wentworth Institute of Technology | D3 | | Archie Williams HS | 2018 |
| Landon | Gregg | Chapman | D3 | Junior | Redwood HS / El Camino College | 2018 |
| Sam | Kinney | Colorado College | D3 | | Marin Academy | 2018 |
| Matt | Redmond | Denison | D3 | | St. Ignatius College Preparatory | 2018 |
| Nik | Burns | Mendocino College | JUCO | Sophomore | Elsie Allen HS | 2018 |
| Justin | Smith | Santa Rosa JC | JUCO | Sophomore | Windsor HS | 2018 |
| Mitch | Hippauf | Simpson University | NAIA | | Vintage HS | 2018 |
| David | Jones | Georgia Southern University | D1 | Junior | Grant HS / Sacramento State / Panola College / Indian Hills CC | 2019 |
| Viktor | Rajkovic | Seattle University | D1 | Junior | Branson / Golden State Prep | 2019 |
| Emmanuel | Adeoye | Texas A&M Commerce | D2 | | Salesian College Preparatory / Angelina College | 2019 |
| Damiri | Lindo | University of Nebraska - Kearney | D2 | Junior | Saint Mary's College HS / Golden State Prep / Holy Names | 2019 |
| Garrett | Siebels | Dominican University | D2 | Senior | Casa Grande HS / Santa Rosa JC | 2019 |
| Quinten | Vermuelen | Dominican University | D2 | | Analy HS | 2019 |
| Aidan | Demian | Oberlin College | D3 | | The Branson School | 2019 |
| Sean | Ingoglia | Union College | D3 | | Stuart Hall / Salisbury School | 2019 |
| Joe | Silveira | Franciscan University of Steubenville | D3 | Senior | Berean Christian / San Diego Christian / Solano College | 2019 |
| Isiaha | Garza | Mendocino College | JUCO | | Elsie Allen HS | 2019 |
| Donniel | Johnson | Mendocino College | JUCO | | Oakland Tech HS | 2019 |
| Trey | Chapman | Essex Rebels (England) | PRO | | Healdsburg HS / Hawaii Pacific University | 2019 |
| Shakir | Howard | South Bay Flash (TBL) | PRO | Junior | Fairfield HS / Napa Valley College / Southern California Leadership University | 2019 |
| Lucas | Saleh | CS Maristes (Lebanon) | PRO | | Prolific Prep / Feather River College / Univ. of Buffalo / Belmont Abbey College | 2019 |
| Jack | Greenwood | Linfield College | D3 | Junior | Marin Catholic | 2020 |
| Peyton | Mullarkey | Pomona-Pitzer | D3 | Junior | The Branson School / Golden State Prep | 2020 |
| Blake | Murray | College of Marin | JUCO | | Vintage HS | 2020 |
| Dylan | Hayman | University of Incarnate Word | D1 | Junior | Healdsburg HS | 2021 |
| Nick | Greenwood | George Fox | D3 | Junior | Marin Catholic | 2021 |
| Sean | McCarthy | Chapman University | D3 | Junior | Tamalpais HS / Tilton School | 2021 |
| Lucq | Anderson | College of the Redwoods | JUCO | Sophomore | Marin Catholic | 2021 |
| Devin | Mims | College of Marin | JUCO | Sophomore | Sacred Heart Cathedral / Tamalpais HS | 2021 |
| Brayden | Greenlee | Carolina University | NCCAA | | Napa HS / Golden State Prep | 2021 |
| Joaquim | Arauz-Moore | Gonzaga University | D1 | Freshman | The Branson School / SoCal Academy | 2022 |
| Will | Heimbrodt | Seattle University | D1 | Freshman | Archie Williams HS / SoCal Academy | 2022 |
| Dom | Girish | Colorado School of Mines | D2 | Sophomore | Sonoma Valley HS | 2022 |
| Nolan | Bessire | Bowdoin | D3 | Sophomore | Montgomery HS | 2022 |
| Noah | Deitch | Lake Forest College | D3 | Sophomore | Marin Catholic HS | 2022 |
| Will | Logue | Bowdoin | D3 | Sophomore | Santa Rosa HS | 2022 |
| Charles | Preston | Occidental College | D3 | Sophomore | Archie Williams HS | 2022 |
| Charlie | Treene | Pomona-Pitzer | D3 | Sophomore | Redwood HS | 2022 |
| Isidro | Garcia | College of the Redwoods | JUCO | Freshman | Santa Rosa HS | 2022 |
| Andrew | Pengel | Santa Rosa JC | JUCO | Sophomore | Rancho Cotate HS | 2022 |
| Salim | Arikat | Menlo College | NAIA | Freshman | Petaluma HS / SoCal Academy | 2022 |
| Drew | Krilich | University of Puget Sound | D3 | Freshman | Cardinal Newman HS | 2023 |
| Kaleb | McKenzie | College of Marin | JUCO | Freshman | Montgomery HS | 2023 |
| Gavin | Reid | Mendocino College | JUCO | Freshman | Analy HS | 2023 |
| Gavin | Vogensen | Santa Rosa JC | JUCO | Freshman | Cardinal Newman HS | 2023 |
